Looking really good now. Too cold and concrete like. No, don’t consider painting the fireplace right now. Listen, the chances are 2% that it’s something we would actually do out of sheer fear of permanence. Stir well to mix the paint and water. Famed for their earthy beauty and unpretentious air of comfort, stacked stones have long been celebrated within the rustic interior. (and yes, with the black ceiling …. A normal repair and restoration of a marble fireplace like this would involve removing the fireplace from site. Stone fireplaces add a touch of natural, rustic beauty to your home. It could be that for months, we were saying the exciting phrase “German Schmear” all day, every day when we could have been just saying “plaster”, but where’s the fun in that. it looks fantastic! Stain the ceiling black!! Mantle – When you added the darker floor color (with your light ceilings), I was attracted to a mantle that was on the darker side (vs the lighter ceiling color family). As to the mantel colour – I like wood. I LOVE the after and on the stone and I am so glad you “made it work,” rather than reconstructing. The new fireplace and chimney breast is a fantastic upgrade! It is gorgeous just as it is, but how striking to be in black and white (like the above photo). Refinish the mantel in a midtone that balances between the ceilings and the floors and the house is ready for the next step. I think the mantel question isn’t the stone or the mantel, it’s the ceiling…. So, clean the stone with TSP, rinse well and allow at least 24 hours to dry. But ours aren’t as flat or jagged and are a lot newer (from the ’80s or ’90s). 4. Great job figuring out a good solution. 2) This is a hard one and I don’t think a decision could be reached until the flooring is actually installed and the firebox has been darkened. So I vote for the black ceiling. as you can imagine, he thinks our whole social media experiment and how we create all this ridiculous on-camera Insta storyiPhonee content is HILARIOUS and is always like “Well, have you asked that audience yet”…SUCH a good sport. Oh, and when looking at the mantle options, I feel that because the floor colour is so off in those examples, none of them really works. Nothing objectionable there. Great update so far! It was built with real stones, not fake, in a fairly random pattern, not looking too forced. 3) Sure, 3-D render it, but dark ceilings just suck up light in photographs, generally. Meanwhile, he’s suspended from being an SBEH freelance camera phone photographer. The tone of the stone isn’t bad – it’s gray, not too brown. 1. Thanks for going this route and showing us. And the whole point of a mountain cabin is lots of wood tones so please oh please don’t paint that ceiling. I think it would be cool and alleviate your wood tone mismatch concerns. 2.) We get it… Ads are annoying. There you have it. My input on your questions: please don’t paint the stone. I just feel like a dose of moody drama works for a cozy mountain house. Good call out and boy is that pretty. It looks so much better than white or black. In regards to the mantle, I think the white or the black will both work. Painting a Stone Fireplace. … Can’t wait to see the next installment. I don’t know the exact tone, but I like it natural. I think the fireplace looks great! Brian is going to LOSE HIS SCHMEAR over even the suggestion of this one…and TBH, it’s likely not going to happen, but it’s fun to fantasize…, Update: Check out all of The Mountain House REVEALS here: The Kids’ Bedroom | The Kitchen | The Kitchen Organization | The Kitchen Appliances | The Powder Bath | The Living Room | The Downstairs Guest Suite | The Loft | The Hall Bath | The Upstairs Guest Bath | The Dining Room | The Family Room. 1) Please don’t paint over the fireplace. Here’s a cottage (for holiday rent) in England with these kinds of walls for comparison …, https://www.character-cottages.co.uk/all-properties/cotswolds-all/angel-cottage. I like the grey mantel. Try wiping the hearth down with water and see if the color works better. (P.S. As for the mantle, I don’t have a “YES!” moment with any of the images. The whole “permancy” thing is what’s making my opinion waver…but I’d love to see the rock painted white and the ceilings plus mantle stained black. I say remove the mantel. Love the idea of trying to make something to blend with the stone of the fireplace – maybe something plastered with the schmear or a mantel veneered with a matching stone, that will look like just a big chunk of stone (the kind I remember them using on This Old House to make outdoor stairs out of – they would just take a big chunk of grey granite that was like 10 inches high and use it for a stair step – that always amazed me). I couldn't imagine not having a fireplace in the living room, it is almost a necessity! Also – if you are in the Chicago area and want to buy some medicine cabinets for what I paid, please let me know. regarding this, “just explore the idea of using that gorgeous black stain on the…CEILING”. In fact, my mom had a wonderful painting of the wailing wall in Jerusalem on the wood mantel. You did such an amazing job and this is actually an attainable solution for many people’s not-quite-right fireplaces. I like this idea!! Love the way the stone turned out! It’s then that we were told that German schmear was just a technique, not a material (we think…again, we welcome any information or suggestions). Nothing some schmear can’t fix. Just goes to show some small changes can have real impact. Black ceiling? Google “stone fireplace mantel” to see what the other options are. NOW! That is an indigenous stone to Wisconsin and reminds me of something I would expect to see in an ancient ruin, but not as crumbly. A fireplace is one thing that can make any room instantly better. PLEASE do not stain those ceilings black or paint the stone!!! Make sure you use only diluted solutions of orthophosphoric acid (the concentration of acid should be less than 5 percent). 5. I LOVE the light “painted” stone photo though!!! Do not make the fireplace all light-colored. LOVE the fireplace! I would then re-assemble or box up the two sides, which would be nice and square to make fitting easier when returned to the property. There’s so much wood in the house (beautiful!) Holy Schmoley, that looks perfect! If anything, paint or stain the wood or vary your flooring. Great job! However, their selection of a stack stone pattern was a little concerning. Basically Emo Vaguely Danish Emily is an interesting concept for all of us to watch. As fall approaches, I am looking forward to wood fires in our newly updated fireplace. . See more ideas about fireplace remodel, fireplace makeover, fireplace design. The Brick-Anew Stone Fireplace Paint Kit includes everything you’ll need for your stone fireplace makeover – all the tools for your project plus 5 shades of paint. Whitewash on the ceiling, depending what you do to the floor might be an option. No no no no. Basically, it made it look like it did when it was wet, but not shiny. BLACK MANTEL. We gave George the direction to even out the rocks, but in a natural way. https://www.flickr.com/photos/army_arch/3622079160/, https://www.pinterest.com/pin/78953799695310869/. They make color enhancing sealers for stone. Note: Before beginning this project, check your local building codes. I think the contrast would be perfect with the now lovely, German-schmeared mantle. I vote for painting the stone. The customers that recently contacted me for a fireplace resurfacing were considering a stack stoned look. They said it would be REALLY white, and so I figured, why not? We are pretty happy for now. Bat cave. I’m making stuff up. I vote yes! If your fireplace needs a reface, here we will show you step by step how to do it yourself.Your fireplace is most likely the centerpiece of your living room. Hi Erin But less-so in person. Please don’t paint over the stone/plaster. At first I didn’t know what the fuss was about: sure, the fireplace had this 80′ vibe, but I liked it better than your dream fireplace nevertheless:D. I’ve looked all over the internet for images but I unfortunately can’t seem to find any, but my parents had a similar two story fireplace in their last home with a chunky limestone mantle and it was beautiful! Gwen that is what I was thinking with the hearth. How to Precast a Stone Fireplace. Stacked stone definitely has its place in the building construction market. What a difference a schmear makes! I do think exploring something more rustic is worth it, the straight mantle seems a little out of place? Now is the time to schedule the Masonry Cosmetics team for your transformation!”, 1970's Stone Fireplace Before & After Hello Fellow DIYers! If you find persistent stains, clean the fireplace with orthophosphoric acid, which is ideal for stone and cast stone cleaning and may also eliminate rust. I have to admit I’m fearless when it comes to painting brick or stone. reminds me of the south of france. He humored me all day and was lovely to work with. And that’s for $1000. And you may have looked at pictures of painted stone that looks, well... painted, and thrown your hands up saying you would rather have a…, 35 Classy Painted Brick Fireplaces Ideas To Try This Month. Just hearing that word makes me smile. Jackhammer the fireplace to create a more even surface by chipping off some of the larger projecting stones. No time to get more options and again, I had very little hope that changing the slight tone of it would make it better. If anyone actually knows the answer, please leave it in the comments and we’ll update the post.). Over the years these components can get damaged, wear out or no longer fall within modern code requirements. I love it now, and don’t think you need to paint over it. Agree. The other reason she couldn’t really remove the mantle all together (as she states in the post) is because the stone above the mantle “juts in” – By this I believe she means that the stone below the mantle is a greater depth than above. It may be because I don’t know what you’re going to do with the rest of the room. The scale of the mantle you are considering, cuts the drama of the stone in half and kind of reads, “requisite chunky wood mantle, check!” No matter the finish it is going to relate to the floor and to the ceiling in some way and be such a focal point, that I fear will always read a little 1980s because of the fact that it is a corner fireplace. . These cookies do not store any personal information. Separating the individual pieces, before removing the old adhesive and cleaning them up. I wanted to title this “DIY Plaster Fireplace,” but obviously couldn’t because I didn’t DIY it. Yesterday my contractor sent me the below photo now that it’s dried: Even better! This is an interesting option. Its the same kind of coziness without the permanence, plus its only paint, and like the stone fireplace it can be changed easily with paint if you don’t like the color it is going forward, its a easier diy project. Some spaces would be deeper than others and then with the trowel and sponge he would make them even less even. Love the fireplace schmear! I know some people suggested no mantle, but that would leave a giant empty space to contend with. No black ceiling. Thank you for sharing!! But then the other option could be amazing….. lolove the way you make “schmear” into “old world flair”, even teasing the masonry guy about it I’ve got a few degrees in German, and a few years lived in a Germany, to Get the humor. But that’s my gut feel. I was just thinking that something natural stone would be my pick for the mantle, maybe even imitating the slate tile hearth, but I also really like this limestone option. I was thinking the same thing, actually! So New England-y. Whether you’re contemplating a full-on renovation or looking for an easy weekend upgrade, get inspired by these ideas that will transform your hearth to the heart of your decor. Link in bio.•••#falldecor #fallisintheair #fallvibes #falldecor #romabio #romabioavoriowhite #romabioclassicolimewash #november #thankfulthursday #outdoorliving #southernlivingmag #countrylivingmag #bhghome #mybhg #mysouthernliving #smpliving #lovewhereyoulive Design by @shelly_d, A Bold, Black Fireplace Makeover | Design*Sponge, “Before and after shots of a fireplace makeover. Before: The stone fireplace was stained and looked dated. Plus, down the line you can always change it if you want, that’s an easy, non-construction-y change. The only thing that I’m still considering is painting over the plaster. Number of coats will depend on the coverage you are looking for. I LOVE the makover! Pour one bag of stucco mix (base coat) into a large mixing container. You nailed it!:D. While I think I’ll never take on a similar project: I love this post. Emily, congratulations on the new finish on the fireplace! We are working on our tall fireplace and are going to have to brick it and then schmear it! We sourced a faux finisher from LA but didn’t find anyone who had this in their portfolio who was affordable. Too matchy with the ceiling. Allow the surface to dry. So if you want the fireplace to stand out, make the surrounding area recede with a mild color, and the fireplace a contrasting color. I think the fireplace looks absolutely great as-is – PLEASE don’t paint it! Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. I would rest a new bigger mantel over the old one ( made out MDF and possible clad in a slate or similar stone ) almost the colour of your hearth . Scrub the surface with a stiff-bristle scrub brush. Since this is not just to live in, but for content, the photographs could be a struggle. My my…:D All you do is water down your paint (20 to 30%), and brush away. Install a Fireplace Mantel and Add Stone Veneer Facing 7 Steps. Even if they could somehow fill the “hole” where the mantle was, the upper and lower sections wouldn’t line up! My 2 cents: Leave your ceiling walnut blasted as-is, stain the beams black, paint the whole fireplace lighter like the picture you’ve referenced, stain the mantel black and darken the hearth to coordinate with the mantel. I just wish one were darker and lighter. For outdoor pathways, it may be easier to use a pressure washer. dreamy. I like a good rock, too, but I wanted ours to feel either more aged and organic OR new and fresh. Whitewash Your Brick or Stone Fireplace With CHALK PAINT® - Chalk It Up Norcross If you have thought about brightening up your brick or stone fireplace, Annie Sloan Chalk Paint is your answer! Clever Pin By Karen Matthews On Fireplace Bricks on Home Decor 42+ Cool Fireplace Stone Painting, Creative 25 Best Ideas About Painted Stone Fireplace On on Home Decor 42+ Cool Fireplace Stone Painting, How to Build a Fireplace Bump Out to Hang a TV | How to Hang a TV over Fireplace When Mantle is Too High | Fireplace Hack by Dans le Lakehouse, To paint or not to paint brick or stone fireplaces is always a big decision. It’s EXTREMELY textured and I’m very excited about it for the kitchen (stay tuned…also could I possibly make life more complicated?). With many of these fireplace makeovers, the homeowners aim to correct the mistakes of previous owners. That way black furniture and accents would look so cool against the background textures. Cover it up with framing and drywall. what an amazing transformation! Wash the cast stone fireplace with warm water and dish detergent. More involved fireplace makeovers might incorporate a lightweight masonry product called manufactured veneer stone, perfect for do-it-yourself work. Things are questioned that I would have assumed were an immovable “given”. 3. My apologies for it being blown-out and pixelated. You may also need a wire brush to remove paint. You voted for us to ‘work’ with the fireplace rock instead of demo-ing it out and starting fresh, perhaps opting for our dream stone or a totally new design (see this post for reference). I show a LOT of ugly houses. This is the original reclaimed wood in its natural form. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. Anyway, great job, and best of luck! Or, tell Brian about it and I bet he’ll veto it for us! This is beautiful reclaimed cedar wood that we painted white gloss for a potential kitchen sample. So bat cave. I don’t know if you would be able to find stone to fill in the gap, but I think the fireplace would look 10 times better without a mantel. A fireplace facelift can take your living space from "whatever" to "wow!" Do you want me to consider painting the fireplace an all-over light tone like above? I think it looks good as is, and I’d like to see how the stone tones wind up working with everything else in the room when the room gets furnished. I’m as shocked as you are that I, Emily-White-Ceiling-Henderson, would even consider staining that massive ceiling black. So yes, spreading your plaster on like peanut butter on toast is the look (and not the product). This fireplace is one that we also liked that seemed more achievable. I think it’s WORLDS better. But we rely upon ads to keep all the posts free for you. They look SO GOOD now. I want it in my house! Fireplace looks great and for such a low price!!! Everything from Restoration Hardware since they became RH is so big, so heavy, so clunky. We didn’t seal it so the grain seeped through (despite 3 coats). I like the white option or the black option for the mantle. Black mantel, no. This makes me think about my home differently: maybe that solid seeming wall in the kitchen could be exposed to create some niche bookshelves…, The schmear seems to have created much more of what you’re striving for. Just my two cents. Remove the dust and soot with a piece of cloth and dust brushes. CEDAR TONGUE-AND-GROOVE MANTEL. Mantle colours: nothing strikes me as right. I am not a big DYI person so I spoke to the amazing contractor Adrian at Craftsman Construction that we worked with on this project, about how they were able to change the multicolored stone fireplace into the c. Want to get rid of an old rock wall but it requires too much demo? But up there, it looks kinda gray on gray on gray. That is how we design, by the way. AND LEARN ABOUT OUR COMMUNITY - WE PROMISE IT’S SUPER COOL. No, don’t do anything with the ceiling right now. (Assuming you’re not using things to bounce the light around for every photograph.) Not because I don’t like the stone but because I fear that medium tone of the stone with the medium tone of the ceiling is kinda competing. Also gorgeous. I was thinking it was limestone as well… there’s no way you’d have such good texture and color variation with painted stone. 10 Brick and Stone Fireplaces! ), https://www.flickr.com/photos/[email protected]/41748543335/, (first time flickr user to apologies if it’s a fail.). It just wasn’t as fresh as I was thinking. I’m intrigues with a metal or limestone mantle possibly. I had a “yes” moment with that and the darker grey flooring. I love all the mountain house content and wish you could share even more about it – this whole series has been fantastic. To be clear – THESE ARE JUST PHOTOSHOPPED RENDERINGS OF THE WOOD ON THE MANTEL. And PLEASE don’t go black on the ceiling! Maybe in a few years, maaaybe. Or will you go down the cast iron route? Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are as essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. An – NO – please do not stain the ceiling black!!! In order to see all our in-post video content, ad blockers must be turned off. You are really amazing! *Also, for what it’s worth, I’m not a professional photographer. Here is how it looked before it dried completely when we left last Friday: DEFINITELY better than the before. Now, after doing a little research and not really being able to come up with a clear answer, we realized (or so we think) the schmear is just how someone applies plaster. But you blow that idea up and make it playful in a masterful and insightful way. Never. I’ll admit I was skeptical as I started reading this, and pleasantly surprised in the end at how much more I like the semi-final result. Please don’t paint the stone. We liked the idea of stone – it’s a mountain house after all – and Brian’s masculinity is highly attached to the amount of wood and rock in this house. “Schmear” just means to spread! (Is this the correct definition for a schmear? A white painted floor would set off the modern look and make the ceiling look better too. *In case you are an ‘I design, You decide’ detective, you’ll probably notice that we didn’t end up raising the firebox. don’t paint the ceilieng will feel off once you get it finished and you will regret it, It may seem a little industrial, but have you considered a metal beam? Darken the slate stone hearth. A fresh coat of black paint on the wood mantel brought focus to the fireplace. Refresh With a New Mantel. This week I thought it would be fun to share some […] I'm Jen. Now this is FAR more special than it looks in that rendering based on just a small piece. However, the hallmark mountain fireplace is more than accessible, and the traditional stacked stone design is most certainly guaranteed to transport you in its own right. Love the fireplace! And the expense? When we didn’t like option #1 or #2, he said that we could just try it in white and I thought…wait, maybe that’s what we wanted anyway? WHITE MANTEL. Spray the stones with a vinegar and water solution. What a transformation! 1. I love the current look because it seems perfectly old world while not trying too hard to be cool. I love that you worked with it and made it into something so beautiful. Assuming once you see the fireplace in person it looks as good as it does in the photo I would save the money for other things. (Although that doesn’t bother me at this point at all). Well, eventually, we realized that it was the darkness of the grout and the depth of the rock that was the problem. I did not like the stone fireplace before – too me the stones were too round and it looked so “new”. Please do us a favor and disable your ad blocker, so we can continue to create the content that you come here to enjoy. Ugh. It was a dark stone and large. It would be gorgeous!! We used some on our slate tile backsplash and it really darkened it while also bringing out the texture and depth of the stone. It’s my totally inexperienced opinion that when it comes to schmear, you can be messier than you would be with other types of plaster. Brian and I (and all of us) were pretty happy already. They were mostly painted fireplace makeovers. It is deeply gratifying that a piece of my art is the centerpiece in our shared family space. I don’t want to like the white one, I want to like the black or wood… but the white … i think i embraces the scandi feel you’re going for without committing to painting the whole thing white, but I think mantle might need some white legs to surround the entire bottom, and to ground it. But, it took us a while to realize why. He didn’t like it when I said ‘schmear’ and I reminded it him the importance of recognizing Old World European phrases that make us kind of uncomfortable, while still being pretentious. Anything contrasting seems like a no, you want something to just blend in. Worst case was that we would plaster it over, dislike the color and then paint it white. The project has to keep moving and frankly I was skeptical that ANYONE could give me the fireplace that I loved, so what did I have to lose? It has so much depth and character right now and it would just look so DIY’d if you paint over it. To enhance the stones' natural color and brilliance, you can easily stain them yourself. I have never been able to decorate it. Lots of people said they could do it, but when our GC said he had someone up there for $1k, we went for it because anyone in LA would have charged more. I’m really loving the stone now—I never dreamed it would look this good! These step-by-step instructions show how to use precast stone to convert a dull-looking fireplace into a stone masterpiece. It was 11:30 am at this point and we had to leave by 4 pm. Answers: Two chairs flanking the fireplace sets up a cozy seating area that's perfect for a two-person conversation or a relaxing evening with a cup of tea and a good book. more about that here) Almost every ugly house (and many perfectly nice houses) have dark, dingy, dirty brick firepla…. I think that the fireplace needs some warmth to it since the stone and grout are so cold grey. I’m starting to realize that it isn’t the color of the mantle so much as the size and placement over the firebox that is the real problem. The whole process took from 9 am to 4 pm – which I think is pretty darn fast. Before and After. GRAY MANTEL. At first, he mixed some gray in the white plaster, but it must have been a fairly warm gray so it looked kinda brown (on the left). Can’t wait what you are going to end up with, I just hope you don’t paint the whole thing white now that the stone looks so pretty! When I saw that last photo I thought, why not stain the ceiling black in the mountain house as well and solve that dilemma. It’s the schmear that kept me here. Brian wants cozy and masculine (plus he’s dark, moody and dramatic!!) Slowly pour water into the stucco mix on one side and mix it with a hoe. I like the black fireplace mantel though and no to painted rock! 2. You are inspiring! Plastering it would look seamless I think.